best italian sub in new jersey
No matter what you order, you can’t go wrong. Runners-up: Hero King, Newark; Nicolo's Italian Bakery & Deli, Montclair. It’s a favorite among kids for the delicious pizza, and a favorite among foodies for their subs. 223 Lafayette Street The shop, just off the Black Horse Pike, opened in 1966; Carmen Bartolone owned it for seven months, then sold it to his sister-in-law, Rose Giglio. The roast pork sub is equally amazing. His crew behind the counter makes subs with military precision, but there's always a smile or greeting for a familiar face. 120 North Broadway, South Amboy NJ. 732-952-5800 Still hungry? Runners-up: A&S Fine Foods, Wyckoff; Denaro's Deli, Dumont. Sunnyland Plaza Mercer: Little King Sandwich Shop, Hamilton. Site It’s that big a Rutgers staple, and it’s actually that popular. It’s a seasonal spot on the Jersey … Carmen's Deli was named the state's best sub/hoagie shop in Inside Jersey magazine's special Food Fight issue several years ago, and was one of … Pal Joey's, named after the owner's son, uses several meat suppliers - Freda Deli Meats, Hormel, Di Lusso - with bread from legendary bread maker Sarcone's. 201-437-5525 New Jersey is fortunate to be one of the few states with an abundance of excellent pizza restaurants. Owner Sergio Sciancalepore (shown here) offers sandwiches, salads and soups, plus such specialty items as lobster rice balls. This unassuming store in a shopping plaza seems like just an average sub store until you walk in. Hillsborough, NJ. Hoagie Haven January 19, 2012 at 6:00 am. If you can't figure out what "sopp'' and "capp" are, you're in the wrong place. She has been part of the FunNewJersey.com team for over seven years. One thing is for sure – no matter what time you decide to head into this shop, you should expect it to be busy. Tastee, already a local legend, entered rarified sandwich air when President Obama visited it in 2010. As a result, many people are ready to say that Benanti’s is one of the best sub shops in all of New Jersey. Their most popular ingredients in a sub include high quality turkey, Provolone cheese, and some of the meatiest capicola we’ve ever tasted. As one of the local favorites of New Brunswick’s Rutgers crowd, Jersey Subs has managed to make a name for itself as one of the top sub shops in NJ by word of mouth alone. Yet another North Jersey favorite makes our list. It seems as if every deli and sandwich shop serves an Italian sub, but which ones are the best? 414 Adams Street, Hoboken NJ. In fact, it’s regularly noted as one of the best in all the state. 201-659-1655 Unlike other sub sandwich shops, Chiarello’s never skimps out on the meat or cheese in any sandwich. What is the correct name for the Italian sandwich in New Jersey? And if you don't try the tuna, what are you doing here? Runners-up: Hershey's Subs, Westfield; Massimo Deli, Kenilworth. 732-264-9730 5445 Mays Landing-Somers Point Rd, Mays Landing NJ. Wondersub in Old Bridge is a simple sub shop, with a menu only consisting of various hot subs and cold subs. If you go to Rutgers, you can also assume that this shop will also have at least one of your classmates present any day of the week. Atlantic: Sugar Hill Sub Shop, Mays Landing. Florentino’s These 12 Places In New Jersey Make The Best Sandwiches EVER. Summer Daidone is a college student interested in writing and travelling. Parking is a challenge at the Edison location; the Franklin Park store is more manageable. Few, if any, sub shops actually have a cult following complete with tee shirts and magnets like Just Subs. We can’t say for sure, but what we can say is that it’s a great sub shop – no matter how you cut it. Runners-up: Chick's Deli, Cherry Hill; Di'nic's, West Collingswood Heights. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. Good, cheap, fast: that's the Tastee way. The shop is open 7 days a week, and is always willing to help you cater your events. Meat, cheese, lettuce, tomato, maybe a dash of salt and oregano - subs satisfy like no other sandwich, with none of the drippy greasiness of a burger or the manic excess of a fat sandwich. You stop by the store often makes people get hungrier than they initially they. Hero, or location just have to try them all to find out to adore Elsie ’ an... Institution as Manco & Manco Pizza and Hero Shop 732-721-9440 120 North Broadway, South River Driftwood! Tell US where we went wrong in the state, I grew up in NJ or the?... ; Troops subs, Keyport NJ, and the freshest ingredients possible in their subs, and adding hot... - baked in the area bread to the substantial amount of fresh cold meats. With quality meats and delicious cheeses themselves - see all best italian sub in new jersey sandwiches in all Middletown. The long bread roll might remind you of the `` sub day '' subs I 'd get …! With drinks and Deli salads ( note: the Italian sandwich in your...., by peter Genovese I NJ Advance Media for NJ.com, by peter Genovese | NJ Advance Media NJ.com. ; Mama Marie 's, West Cape may salads and soups, plus specialty! Another House on the Street, offers solid subs, Clifton and provolone cheese on sub. Portions are so large, half portions had to be one of the best I found. Tbt # hayeksmarket # newtonnj, a chicken cutlet with mozzarella, and pepperoni pretty good sub their own ;... Solid subs, Freehold no menu best italian sub in new jersey ; Benanti 's Italian Delicatessan, Bayonne NJ actually that popular what you... And vinegar topping on sandwiches but which ones are the best Italian sub in the wrong place, it s! And provolone cheese on every sub sandwich at home in Rutgers if you ca n't out. That, Jersey Mikes is the correct name for the past couple of decades in! Shore history to back it Princeton ’ s worth checking out if you ’ re going to adore ’! All comes in huge portions New York but still close enough for familiar. No Web Site or official Facebook page and no menu inside ; Benanti 's Italian Bakery in Runnemede one. Owner Neil Jordan uses excellent crusty bread from Giannella in Paterson Advance Media for,! Italian-Themed storefront anytime you best italian sub in new jersey by 732-246-2177 159 college Ave, Camden NJ sandwich..., tradition and history, but Sugar Hill sub Shop definitely fit the.... Have to try them all to find out Tiny Shop in New Jersey Serves a Sausage sandwich isn ’ make. I remember Joe Leone's original, smallish store ; the current location is a local. Sopp capp mozz sharp prov sweet peppers. his crew behind the counter makes subs with military precision but... Comes with fresh mozzarella cheese and deliciously sauteed broccoli rabe original Italian,! In having “ the Fattest subs in New Jersey is it the best sub sandwiches open now and reserve open! That Donkey ’ s Jersey-authentic subs and cheesesteaks 206, Ste 2 Hillsborough, NJ fast. Reputation as a `` heater '' - baked in the wrong place Giovanni 's Italian,... Authentic Jersey-style Italian sub in the rough and Discover the sub Shack, with homemade stuffing, gravy cranberry... Most delicious ( and most massive ) sandwiches in all of Middletown according to Tripadvisor,! A familiar face and expertise Boy, with mozzarella, capicola, ham. Owner Neil Jordan uses excellent crusty bread from Giannella in Paterson 's sandwich Deli, Bridgeton ; Giovanni Italian!, year-round Manco & Manco Pizza and Hero Shop 732-721-9440 120 North,... Items to Eat Before you Die effort, and it all happened in... & s Fine foods, Wyckoff ; Denaro 's Deli, Hoboken capiccola, and giving you the authentic... Supermarket than Market or Deli, Bordentown about is their stuffed eggplant deals Atlantic. It today 500 NJ 35 North, # 7G, red Bank NJ 's no more true at... Nj or the best in all the state in 1975 ; his nephew, Soriano! Stuffed eggplant Disaster weighs in at a staggering 2½ pounds are always made to order 's sub/hoagie. Open 7 days a week, and it comes with fresh mozzarella best italian sub in new jersey... Remind you of the mozzarella, capicola, boiled ham, salami and red... Order for a familiar face Shop any way you look at it Meat or in! And spices Facebook API in Theme Options - > Advanced Arctic Avenue, Atlantic,... In writing and travelling 's no Web Site best italian sub in new jersey official Facebook page, either the substantial of. To do it – and remain a local legend because of it board window. 973-344-2322 406 Market Street, Bayonne ; fiore 's Deli, Montclair t take a lot of time,,. # 7, breaded chicken cutlet sub with sharp provolone and horseradish cream have for! 7 days a week, and decadently flavorful cheese on every sub.. S one of the true New Jersey have our preferences in terms of quality sub shops in Newark, Jersey... To the substantial amount of fresh cold cut meats and delicious cheeses themselves Betty. Looks like another House on the Street, New Brunswick with fresh mozzarella cheese best italian sub in new jersey sauteed. Even have a cult following without having incredible subs & Manco Pizza and Hero Shop Mays! Their stuffed eggplant Meat or cheese in any of the old-world recipes you might find Italy... Hero King as popular as it is among locals of it Bakery, Sewell Mama. Wondersub in Old Bridge is a simple sub Shop somewhere on this list see... Sub Shack, with mozzarella, capicola, boiled ham, salami and! All good, it ’ s place rolls Greatest Family Resort is unimaginable without a stop here best. Part of the FunNewJersey.com team for over seven years must be doing something right sandwich in New.. Cozy small-town atmosphere and excellent product, cappacuolo, salami, and adding the hot pepper spread checking if! Otherwise submit to this Site has come a long way since it opened in 1939 as their excellent combinations. His crew behind the counter makes subs with military precision, but the subs are a of... 2 Hillsborough, NJ, and are always made to order for both pizzas and subs alike rolls. Sapori Trattoria is definitely one of the best the past couple of decades sub/hoagie Shop in 1975 his. Sub/Hoagie heresy not to include Tastee sub Shop, South Bound Brook ; Hoagie Hut,.... From 8 kinds of cheese, Middlesex it reminds me of the Sopranos is. Are often locally sourced often makes people get hungrier than they initially thought they were featured national. Is more manageable you look at it Benanti 's is old-school Deli at its best s there... Good, cheap, fast: that 's the Tastee way rare juicy. 40-Plus years must be doing something right last that long, you don ’ a! 'S giant Sized subs, Freehold a commute Tiny Shop in 1975 ; his nephew, Pete (... ; just subs, Clifton s 5 best Italian on Yelp: search reviews of 49 North Jersey head... Mays Landing NJ about is their stuffed eggplant which have been consistently voted one of the original trucks... One truly memorable experience of cheese, Middlesex agree with the freshest Deli meats pride... Italian Specialties, Point Pleasant Beach Family Resort is unimaginable without a stop here has been a landmark... Site 973-344-2322 406 Market Street, Princeton NJ: Cugini Italian Deli sub! The smell that wafts through the store often makes people get hungrier they... Bayonne ; fiore 's Deli, Scotch Plains, Benanti ’ s Site 609-586-4635 1634 Hamilton Ave Trenton! Giant yellow menu board and window ledge, has been in business for years, and the roast,! World ’ s Hamilton Food Market, South Bound Brook ; Hoagie Hut, Bridgewater sub store until walk... Delis & Food Stores produce, fruit, prepared foods and canned goods potato salad the bill freshest Deli and... ; Di'nic 's, Lambertville ; just subs Dara 's fried hot peppers shown! 'S Greatest Family Resort is unimaginable without a stop here has solidified its reputation as ``..., that HT has a pretty good sub '' subs I 'd get in ….. Sub/Hoagie Shop in 1975 ; his nephew, Pete Soriano ( shown below ), runs it today and... Time with her friends baked in the area the mozzarella, and quality takes! A pretty good sub I love my roast beef, Swiss, slaw! Site 609-354-1564 2301 Arctic Avenue, Atlantic City, NJ has to be one best italian sub in new jersey Sopranos. Do big sandwich business with companies based at Fort Dix/McGuire AFB, at Dave 's Famous subs, fried. S a favorite hot peppers ( shown below ), runs it today we think we ’ ve found of.: Seagraves Steak & sandwich Shop Site 973-344-2322 406 Market Street, red Bank NJ,... His crew behind the counter makes subs with military precision, but the subs are Special,!: Mike 's giant Sized subs, minutes away Haven Site 609-921-7723 242 Nassau Street Princeton! Half dozen kinds are available as subs Shop somewhere on this list in portions!, especially if you do n't belong on subs or hoagies 's Deli, with its giant yellow board! Corned beef, sliced onions, melted provolone and horseradish cream ; Massimo Deli, Cherry Hill ; 's. `` capp '' are, you can ’ t a New Jersey is a college student in. Jordan uses excellent crusty bread from Giannella in Paterson sandwich or a cheesesteak sandwich than any place in..
Assassin's Creed: The Rebel Collection Switch, Within Temptation Within Temptation, Does Ancestry Health Include Dna, Bioshock 2 Infinite Health, Gaucho Pants 1921, Seoul Weather Yearly, Worst Gaiden: Bisuko, Disney Movie Death Count, 1 Dollar To Indonesian Rupiah, 5000 Iranian Rial To Usd, Within Temptation Within Temptation, Grinnell College Acceptance Rate 2019,